IT support people suffer broadband hell too !!
As someone who often provides advice on which broadband provider to choose, it’s ironic that I have just suffered a 12 day long broadband outage.
Being careful, I have a back-up provider too, but that too has proved to be difficult or scary to use, due to uncertainty over download limits.
It’s getting to the point where I am checking where the free internet cafe’s are in Wakefield, because I am going to need to take my laptop and go and sit there.
The big debate at the moment is whether or not people should choose one of the “big 5″ broadband providers where everything is “bundled” or choose one of the smaller specialist providers who do excellent broadband and little else. It sounds great to have all your phone calls and maybe, TV package in the same place, making savings on broadband, and getting a generous call package, but if something goes wrong, you will soon realise the changes that have taken place over the last few years, as you find yourself navigating an automatic phone line menu, and speaking to people in other countries who staff the modern call centres … and then there’s the 12 or 18 month lock-in and you find you cannot change to someone else for a long time …
So what’s my story? Let’s name and shame …
I switched my main broadband for cost reasons, a year ago. I was paying £30 a month to Zen, for a business service that was capped at 50GB download per month, but was reliable, and fast enough at 8MB download, which it usually attained. I got this down to £19 per month, for an unlimited service that was supposed to go as fast as 24MB down – 3 times that of the previous provider. For a long time, I was very pleased with the service I got from “Betherenow”. (Now part of the O2 group).
Only this year, I realised that the speed had dropped considerably, and even though it was still unlimited and stable, I was only getting download speeds of between 3 & 4MB – a lot less than advertised, and half the speed of the previous provider. I checked my contract and found I needed to give 3 months notice to cancel.
In itself, this wasn’t a big thing, as I could put up with the slower speeds until the contract ended, sometime in February I calculated.
Then I found the only way you could cancel was by ringing a “cancellation” line. I soon realised, when I rang the line in late November, that this was actually a “persuade the customer not to cancel” line. They offered to fix the problem, send a new router and give me a free month, all of which sounded great, so naturally I took them up on it.
When they wanted to send a third router, and the line was still going slow, I started to realise this would not be straightforward. Eventually, they sent a BT Openreach engineer, who said the line was fine. (It’s interesting to see the relationship between BT and other providers – to say this is not an ideal situation may well be an understatement). I was told that the line was to be re-connected at the local exchange, and that this would fix the problem. In actual fact, things got worse – even though the 3rd Bebox would connect at speeds up to 8MB, there was no onward connection to the internet anymore, so I was actually much worse off.
As well as complaining bitterly, one of the first things I had to do, was stop hosting my web site at home, and move it onto the internet itself. I found a member of the family who had some web space I could use, and moved it there.
Next, it was time to look at the back-up internet provider. Now, my backup was Sky Broadband, part of a package from Sky, which was free for the first year. This worked fine, but was only the base package, 2MB download speed, and a 2GB download cap per month. I found I used that up in a couple of days – in fact, just Windows updates accounted for most of it! Looking at the Sky web site, I expected to find a charging system for the extra download used, but instead, they stated they would update me to the NEXT package automatically. I didn’t want that, because there was a one year minimum contract attached, and I didn’t think it was LEGAL to upgrade somebody without their consent. A day or so later (probably after calls from outraged customers) they had changed their web site to say customers would not be upgraded if they went over their limit. I also noticed that Sky’s broadband monitoring tools appeared to be patchy, inaccurate and often, simply not working at all. I just hoped that Betherenow would fix their service soon.
11 days after I first lost the broadband connection, and another BT Openreach engineer later, my service was restored, albeit at the same slow download speed as before this all started, and I have to say, with a fairly patchy internet connection. It seems to have a faulty domain name service, where some web sites will work, while others won’t. I cannot understand how Facebook will work OK, while at the same time, I cannot do a Google search – BUT – I am past complaining to Betherenow. They have cancelled the service, and reduced the notice period to one month, so it will all go away come mid January 2010. Now I have to find a new main provider. So far, with my back-up provider SKY, I have used 14GB instead of 2GB, so am about 7 times over my limit, but apparently, as long as I don’t do this again, in the next 5 months, I will not be penalised.
In my next blog, I will let you know which provider I decide to go with next. I will be checking out this web site: www.ispreview.co.uk and seeing what other people think about their providers. At the moment, I am leaning towards Zen Internet, or maybe Eclipse who are now owned by Kingston Communications, but have recently upgraded their email service to make it more reliable.
In summary, this has been an awful experience – I thought I would be without broadband over Christmas.
I think the “big 5″ internet service providers are looking to grab market share and are competing on price and long “bundled” special deals, whilst sacrificing quality of service, customer service and download speeds – in reality what they advertise and what you get bear little relation to each other.
Sky are a great TV provider, but it’s clear that broadband is not their top priority right now.
If you want good broadband, don’t go to a jack-of-all trades – get it from a specialist – and preferably one with a UK based help desk. I think it’s time people voted with their feet!!